Sonic Death – Sonic Youth Live
Ecstatic Peace
Recorded 1981-1983
Released 1984
Track List (approximate):
Side A
The Good and the Bad (partial)
She is Not Alone (partial)
The Good and the Bad (partial)
The World Looks Red (Sped up)
Confusion is Next
Inhuman (fragment)
Shaking Hell (fragment)
Burning Spear
Side B
Brother James (fragment)
Early American
Burning Spear (fragment)
Kill Yr Idols
Confusion Is Next (fragment)
Kill Yr Idols (fragment)
Shaking Hell (fragment)
(She’s in A) Bad Mood
(She’s in A) Bad Mood
“The next song is called Shaking Hell. Suck my dick, asshole.” –Thurston Moore
Here we have the most vexing release featured so far, the Sonic Death cassette. This tape is essentially a collage of Sonic Youth live recordings from 1981-1983, released on Thurston Moore’s label Ecstatic Peace in 1984. Sonic Death was reissued by SST a few years later, though is now long out of print. As you might infer from the words “collage” and “Sonic Youth live” in the same sentence, this release is a fucking mess. Brain-melting. I began this review weeks ago, and after continuously rewinding the tape and trying to make intellectual sense of it, I broke. My head felt like mush, I was overwhelmed with anxiety, and I just couldn’t take it anymore. I had to set this project down and figure out what critical engagement with this piece even means, or whether it’s required/possible at all. Let’s face it, much what is happening on this tape is unintelligible and downright taunting. The quote above, taken from about 58 minutes in, sums up this recording as well as I ever could.
This tape is par for the course for the first major label band to have 100% creative control over their output. Throughout their career spanning across four decades, Sonic Youth consistently pushed the envelope, putting out proper studio releases that consistently expanded the definition of what could be considered rock music, and more casual projects that often border on the absurd. I mean, this is the band that got Neil Young to put out Arc, a record that entirely consists of the closing feedback and snippets of random songs performed on their 1991 tour together. My personal favorite SY moment is their presence on the Simpsons episode “Homerpalooza”, stealing watermelon from Peter Frampton and performing a circuslike rendition of the end credits that only they could pull off.
While inferences can be made about what comprises Sonic Death, there are no dates of when any of these songs are recorded, where, by who, or who even played on them, as during this stint they had 3 different drummers (Richard Edison, Jim Sclavunos, and Bob Bert). There are references to Swans, suggesting some of these recordings could be from their storied 1982 tour together, which falls in line with the general timeframe given for the recordings. What we can be certain of is that it contains material from their first 3 releases (The self-titled EP, the debut LP Confusion is Sex, and the Kill Yr Idols EP), and that the unit performing them goes by Sonic Youth. It clocks in at around 70 minutes, there is no track listing on the tape itself (track listing listed above was cross referenced with studio recordings, may not be 100% accurate and perhaps you have your own insight on what song is under minutes straight of unison hits feedbacking chaos, in which case be my guest). Few of these recognizable songs are presented in their entirety, and even when they are there’s a catch, whether it be sped up, skipped, or with multiple versions of the same song smattered across the tape. A track by track review of this record is futile for this reason, and I have decided to forgo this type of analysis.
What I will give you is this: I have found a couple modes of experiencing this tape. For a while my listens were casual, background at a medium low volume while I drove around, giving me the same sort of comfort that faint, lo fi black metal provides, with brief interjections of entertaining banter. The second, where I am engaged, hanging on every hit, chime of their signature Jazzmasters, and general industrial clamor, drives me to my psychological limits and leaves me dazed for weeks. Pick your poison.

